A visit to Myers Dinner Theater is like discovering a treasured slice of Americana where hearty meals and live theatrical performances blend into a uniquely warm and nostalgic outing. First opened by Richard and Donna Myers in the early 2000s, this intimate dinner theater has been a Hillsboro staple for more than two decades, inviting locals and road‑trippers alike to enjoy big‑hearted entertainment paired with generous home‑cooked food.
Occupying a charming building with vintage flair in this small Fountain County town, Myers Dinner Theater quickly becomes more than “just a show.” Its cozy atmosphere — complete with a welcoming lobby, the smell of fresh food wafting from the kitchen, and a stage set for community‑spirited performances — makes the experience feel genuinely like more than the sum of its parts.
Best Things to Experience
The heart of Myers Dinner Theater is, of course, its lively stage productions. Throughout the season, you’ll find everything from Broadway musicals and classic plays to lighter‑hearted comedies and family‑friendly productions, all performed with an enthusiastic troupe that often includes both seasoned actors and local talent. The intimate space means you’re never far from the action, and sightlines are generous so nearly every seat feels close to the performance.
Dinner here isn’t an afterthought — it’s part of the draw. Before the curtain rises, a buffet‑style meal awaits, featuring hearty comfort‑style fare like roasted chicken, meatloaf, mashed potatoes, green beans, and homemade rolls that have earned compliments from many visitors. The menu often complements the evening’s theme, and desserts like apples or cobbler finish the meal on a sweet, satisfying note.
For those with an eye for charm, the theater’s interior is part of the experience. Thoughtful decorative touches give the space a homey feel — from themed restrooms to classic stage‑set pieces and vintage signage — helping bridge the gap between a historic small‑town vibe and an enjoyable live‑performance setting.
The connection to the community looms large here. The theater’s history of welcoming families, bus groups, and repeat visitors lends it a hometown quality you simply don’t find in larger dinner theaters. It’s cozy, it’s personable, and the shared experience with neighbors and fellow travelers gives each show a communal energy that feels special.
Inside the Atmosphere
Walking into Myers Dinner Theater feels like arriving at a family gathering where dinner and entertainment are equally important. The lobby greets you with the promise of hearty food, and once your seating is announced, the interior unfolds like a living room‑turned‑stage. Ambient lighting and modest décor keep the focus on the performance, while the scent of fresh‑made dishes adds an extra layer of warmth.
The compact seating plan — usually accommodating around 150 guests — means that even group performances retain a sense of closeness. You’ll notice frequent laughter, applause, and cheerful chatter flowing easily throughout the evening. Many guests treat this outing as both dinner and social event, lingering between acts or at intermission to savor both food and conversation.
Other Considerations
What should you know before you go? Planning ahead is wise here — performances can sell out, especially on weekend evenings or during popular shows. Tickets are available through the theater’s website or by calling the box office, and reservations help ensure you get both your meal and your preferred showtime.
Is it family‑friendly? Yes — the theater caters to a broad range of ages with selections of shows that appeal to both adults and children alike. With seating and food options that embrace a casual dining experience, it’s an outing that can be shared across generations.
How’s the pricing? Compared to big‑city dinner theaters, Myers offers strong value. Ticket packages often combine meal and performance for a single price, with options for show‑only admission if you prefer. Group rates and occasional discounts can make it even more budget‑friendly, particularly for clubs, families, or touring parties.
Any drawbacks? A few visitors note that not every show or dish will be a home run for everyone, and since productions often feature a blend of local and professional talent, performance quality can vary from one season to the next. But for many guests, that variability only underscores the charm of a true community theater.
Myers Dinner Theater
📍 108 N Water St, Hillsboro, IN 47949, USA
Website: https://myersdt.com
