Hickie’s Hamburger Inn is a New Boston institution — a classic, unpretentious, old-school diner that has quietly become one of southern Ohio’s most beloved burger destinations. This tiny but mighty restaurant is nearly always packed with locals, and it won’t take you long to find out why. What you’ll find here isn’t fancy or flashy — it’s just honest, homemade food served in a setting that feels like it belongs to a time when things were simpler and better.
The name apparently comes from the last name of the original owners: Hickman. It’s a true classic in Scioto County, Ohio — the kind of place that gets passed down through generations of loyal fans and always manages to win over first-timers, too.
Menu Highlights
The Burgers
Renowned for its hot and delicious burgers, Hickie’s offers tender, juicy patties freshly made to perfection. Diners rave about the delightful sliders wrapped in wax paper, perfectly complementing the crispy, skinny fries that add an irresistible crunch to every bite. The slider-style format means you’ll likely want to order more than one — and that’s perfectly by design. These little beauties come loaded with mustard, onions, cheese, and pickles for a straightforward, no-fuss burger experience that delivers every time.
The Fries
There is a lot of well-earned hype surrounding the Hickie’s hamburgers, but the fries may just be the most impressive thing on the menu — perhaps the best some visitors have ever had. Crispy, skinny, and freshly made, they’re the kind of side dish that steals the show. If you’re a fry connoisseur, don’t sleep on this one.
The Big Otis & The Yogi
The menu also features the massive Yogi sandwich for those who want something with a little more heft. The Big Otis burger is another standout that regulars swear by — a step up from the sliders and worth every bite. These named menu items give the restaurant a personality all its own.
Hot Dogs & Homemade Sauces
Hickie’s is also well known for its hot dogs served with a deeply flavorful homemade sauce. The homemade hot dog sauce and Ohio-style poutine add a unique regional flair to the offerings, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts. It’s the kind of regional cooking you simply won’t find replicated anywhere else.
Soups & Chili
Homemade bean soup is another standout, showcasing a commitment to quality ingredients and heartfelt flavors. The chili is very tasty and draws its own loyal following — an excellent choice for cooler days when you want something warm and satisfying. Everything is homemade, and that dedication to from-scratch cooking comes through in every single dish on the menu.
Atmosphere & Décor
The friendly and efficient staff provides counter or table service in a charming atmosphere filled with local sports team memorabilia. It’s the kind of décor that tells the story of a community — pennants, photos, and local pride displayed with no pretense whatsoever. Walking in feels less like entering a restaurant and more like stepping into a neighborhood living room.
The restaurant is welcoming, with a homey atmosphere that is rich in friendly service and families enjoying meals together. The space is small and intimate, which contributes to the warm energy that fills the room. The seating arrangement can feel tight for some patrons, but most visitors find that the coziness only adds to the overall charm of the experience.
The burgers here remind some visitors of classic hamburger joints from Cincinnati in the 1950s — and this place will bring back all those beautiful memories. There’s an unmistakable sense of time-travel when you step through the door, and that nostalgia is a big part of what keeps people coming back.
Other Considerations
So, what’s the deal with being a “Hickie’s Virgin”?
It’s a fun local tradition when a “Hickie’s Virgin” — someone on their very first visit — is discovered. Make sure the staff knows it’s your first visit and prepare for a warm welcome that makes the moment memorable. It’s one of those quirky, community-driven touches that sets this place apart from any ordinary burger stop.
How are the prices?
Prices are very reasonable, and the food is packed with flavor, making it a must-stop destination for a taste of Americana. The slider-style burgers are intentionally small and inexpensive, so don’t hesitate to order a couple — your wallet and your stomach will both thank you.
Is it good for families?
The venue provides kid-friendly options such as high chairs, and items like burgers and hot dogs are always a hit with children. The casual, easygoing atmosphere means there’s no stress about keeping things formal — just come as you are and enjoy the food.
What about parking?
Parking is available, but it can be extremely tight. Additional parking may be found on the back streets nearby. Given how popular Hickie’s is, arriving a little early — especially around lunchtime — is always a smart move.
When is it open?
Hickie’s is open Tuesday through Friday from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM and Saturday from 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM. It is closed on Sundays and Mondays. The limited hours are part of what makes a visit feel special — plan ahead so you don’t miss out.
Hickie’s Hamburger Inn
📍 3800 Rhodes Ave, New Boston, OH 45662
Website: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Hickies-Hamburger-Inn/115620915125302
