This Downtown Phoenix Restaurant Named Itself After A Butcher Who Thought He Was The Best

A restaurant confident enough to call itself arrogant had better be able to back it up, and this one, planted right in the middle of CityScape, mostly does. The name is a nod to a neighborhood butcher that founder Sam Fox remembered growing up, a guy who was absolutely certain his cuts were the best in town and wasn’t shy about saying so. That swagger became the whole personality of the place.

The Arrogant Butcher opened in 2011 as one of Fox Restaurant Concepts’ first big bets on downtown Phoenix, back when the area around Chase Field and the Footprint Center was still finding its footing as a dining destination. More than a decade later, it’s become one of the steadier anchors of that stretch, pulling in a mix of pre-game crowds, downtown workers, and out-of-towners staying nearby.

What to Order

The Arrogant Butcher
© The Arrogant Butcher

Steak is the obvious centerpiece here, and the roster runs from a slow-roasted prime rib to a filet mignon and a New York strip finished au poivre, all cooked over an open flame in a dining room built around the idea of fire and smoke. The kitchen also leans on a raw bar for oysters and seafood towers, which pairs nicely with the steakhouse side of the menu if you want to split the difference.

The tuna tataki, served over crispy rice, comes up again and again as one of the dishes people order specifically to come back for. Smoked carnitas nachos are piled high enough that two people can make a full meal out of them, and sides like the Brussels sprouts and Japanese sweet potatoes routinely steal attention away from the entrees they’re meant to accompany.

Weekday happy hour, running Monday through Friday from 2 to 5 p.m., is where a lot of regulars get their fix without committing to a full steakhouse tab. It’s built around a shorter, more casual menu of bar bites and discounted drinks, and it’s a smart way to sample the kitchen’s style before splurging on a bigger cut later.

Atmosphere & Décor

The space itself is sizable, built around an open kitchen and a bar area that stays loud and energetic most nights, especially when there’s a Suns or Diamondbacks game letting out nearby. Exposed elements and warm lighting give it that lived-in, “we’ve been here forever” feel that Fox was reportedly going for when the concept was designed, even though the building itself is a modern CityScape build.

There’s also a patio with misters for the warmer months, along with a lounge area and a handful of private dining rooms tucked off the main floor for groups wanting a bit more separation from the noise. Speaking of noise, it’s worth knowing going in: the main dining room can get genuinely loud during peak hours, which fits the vibe but isn’t for everyone looking for a quiet dinner conversation.

Other Considerations

The Arrogant Butcher
© The Arrogant Butcher

Is it good for a pre-game dinner? Very much so. The location puts you within walking distance of Chase Field, the Footprint Center, and the Orpheum Theatre, which makes it a natural stop before or after an event downtown.

What about parking? Guests get two hours of complimentary parking validation when using the CityScape Parking Garage, which takes a lot of the usual downtown parking stress out of the equation.

Can I bring kids? Yes, there’s a dedicated kids menu with options like a cheeseburger, chicken tenders, and mac and cheese, so families are accounted for even in a menu that otherwise skews toward steakhouse fare and cocktails.

Are reservations a good idea? Given how busy the space gets around events and weekend evenings, booking ahead through OpenTable is a smart move rather than showing up and hoping for a table.

The Arrogant Butcher
© The Arrogant Butcher

The Arrogant Butcher
📍 2 E Jefferson St #150, Phoenix, AZ 85004
Website: https://www.thearrogantbutcher.com/locations/phoenix-az/

Elena Ruiz
About the Author:

Elena Ruiz

Elena is a 34-year-old architectural photographer who finds beauty in the harsh contrasts of the desert landscape. She spent her youth hiking the Mogollon Rim and now focuses her writing on the intersection of sustainable design and arid environments. When she isn’t scouting locations, she is usually experimenting with drought-resistant gardening in her backyard. Her prose is precise and observant, aiming to move beyond the typical desert heat tropes. She believes that the true heart of the state is found in its quiet, rocky canyons rather than the crowded tourist hubs.

Browse more by Elena Ruiz

Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.